Dropped shows you might actually resume
Paused, dropped, and up-next are different shelves. If everything abandoned sits in Up Next, you will never trust the next episode button.
After TV Time, people restore years of maybe. Be cruel: a show you have not opened in two years is dropped until you move it back.
Three buckets
Watching, paused with a date you mean, and dropped. Return dates belong on watching and paused. Dropped should not page you when a show comes back unless you ask.
Notifications for returns, not every air, only help if the shelf is honest.
Unfinished is not a moral failing
Limited series you abandoned are allowed to stay abandoned. What to watch next should come from unfinished shows you still want, not from guilt.
Frequently asked questions
Should I delete dropped shows?
Keep them off Up Next. Deleting history makes the next import harder.
What if I remember I finished it?
Mark it finished. Forgotten-show-you-already-finished is a real import bug in your head.